fbpx

Courts

Members of ’98 Constitution Revision Commission file briefs supporting state’s position in adequacy lawsuit

A group of appointed members from a 1998 Constitution Revision Commission filed a legal brief Tuesday arguing the state has fully complied with a constitutional mandate, proposed by the commission and approved by voters that year, requiring Florida public schools to be “high quality” and adequately funded. The CRC contingent was among five different groups that filed amicus briefs supporting the state’s position in the highly charged adequacy lawsuit, and its legal argument was notably at odds with that of a separate group of appointment members who weighed in earlier in July. The adequacy suit, first in 2009 by a Gainesville-based...

Clash emerges on education amendment – two decades later

Jim Saunders / News Service of Florida TALLAHASSEE --- One group, describing itself as the “framers” of an education constitutional amendment, was largely appointed by former Democratic Gov. Lawton Chiles. Another group was appointed by 1990s-era Republican legislative leaders. But two decades after the groups served together on the 1997-1998 Florida Constitution Revision Commission, they are clashing in the state Supreme Court. The root of the clash is an amendment that the Constitution Revision Commission placed on the 1998 ballot that spelled out a duty for the state to provide a high-quality system of public schools. The Florida Supreme Court is now...

Judge puts Palm Beach HB 7069 funding lawsuit on hold

A South Florida school district's bid to recoup facilities funding it shared with charter schools under a 2017 law has to wait for courts to sort out a broader case, a Leon County judge has ruled. The Palm Beach County School Board was first out of the gate to challenge HB 7069 when it passed last year. Its lawsuit is narrow, targeting only the portion of the law requiring it to share local property tax revenue with charter schools it authorizes. More than a dozen other districts subsequently backed a broader lawsuit taking aim at multiple parts of the law, including...

Groups seek to prolong Fla. education lawsuit, revive school choice claims

The groups behind a wide-ranging lawsuit that argues Florida has violated its constitutional mandate to provide a high-quality education want to hit the reset button on the case. In court papers filed Monday with the state Supreme Court, attorneys with Southern Legal Counsel argue a trial court erred when it dismissed their lawsuit on all counts. They also argued an appeals court erred when it ruled that declaring wide swaths of education funding and policy unconstitutional would encroach on the powers of other branches of government. As a result, they argue, the high court should send the case back to the...

Fla. constitutional ‘framers’ want to weigh in on education adequacy lawsuit

News Service of Florida Some members of Florida's 1998 Constitution Revision Commission are seeking to file a brief in the Florida Supreme Court as part of a legal battle about whether the state is meeting its constitutional duty to provide a high-quality system of public schools. Describing themselves as the “framers” of a 1998 ballot measure that put the duty in the Constitution, the former commissioners filed a motion Tuesday asking for approval to file a friend-of-the-court brief. A footnote in the motion indicates 10 former commissioners want to join in the brief, including former Attorney General Bob Butterworth, former Supreme...

A new legal battle over Florida charter school capital funding rules

Another charter school is tangling with the Florida Department of Education, arguing its D letter grades shouldn't cause it to lose state capital funding. Kids Community College's Orange County school received consecutive D's from the state in both the 2015-6 and 2016-17 school years. New department rules, adopted last year, disqualify the school from state facilities funding. Those rules did not take effect without controversy. Several small charter school operators challenged the proposed rules and forced the department to delay them. As a result, the new rules took effect for the 2017-18 school year. However, the school argues its letter grades from previous...

Florida Supreme Court agrees to hear wide-ranging education lawsuit

Education activists hoped to put two decades of Florida education policy, and above all, funding, on trial. They will get their wish before the state Supreme Court. The high court agreed today, in a 4-1 decision, to hear appeals in the so-called "adequacy lawsuit." Alan Lawson, a new appointee of Gov. Rick Scott, was the lone vote against hearing the case. The suit, first filed by education activists in 2009, argues Florida's public schools are under-funded and hamstrung by policies like standardized testing, in violation of the state constitution. In 2014, the scope of the case widened considerably, and the plaintiffs took aim...

HB 7069 ruling shines light on long-simmering charter school disputes

Florida school districts have long asserted the power to approve and reject would-be charter schools as they saw fit. Legal gray areas remain. But a recent court ruling could help clarify some of them. The state constitution gives school boards the power to oversee all public schools within their boundaries. However, it also gives the Legislature and state Board of Education the power to regulate their use of that authority. The tension between state and local power has been at the heart of more than a decade's worth of legal battles over charter schools. Districts won a crucial legal victory in...