The teacher union’s amusing hypocrisy about Big $ in politics

John Kirtley

Editor’s note: This post was originally published as an op-ed in today’s Orlando Sentinel. The state’s tax credit scholarship program is administered by Step Up For Students, which co-hosts this blog.

follow the moneyThe politics of school choice are particularly unforgiving these days, but one of the messages being sold in this year’s Florida legislative session is amusingly hypocritical.

The backdrop is a bill to strengthen a scholarship that for the past 12 years has provided some economically disadvantaged Florida children access to private schools. Though the effort has been cast by opponents as a dramatic expansion, the bill headed for a House floor vote on Friday has been changed so it no longer contains either an increase in the statewide cap or a sales-tax credit — two of the most contentious parts. It’s worth remembering that this scholarship is the only choice program with a statewide cap.

In politics, though, the size of the debate doesn’t always conform to the size of the legislation. The Florida Education Association has launched an aggressive campaign to block it, including a requisite attempt to discredit the supporters. But what is especially entertaining is the FEA’s feigned shock that scholarship advocates might invest in political campaigns involving Democrats.

The FEA is distributing a video from a 2011 school-choice conference in Berkeley, Calif., that features Doug Tuthill, who is president of the nonprofit that administers the tax-credit program and a former chapter president for FEA. The conference was put together by a group that includes many liberal academicians who appreciate the historical role teachers unions have played in providing financial support for Democrats. But they asked him how to break that grip because they are dismayed the money now comes with a prohibition on voting for private school choice.

Tuthill’s answer was honest and direct: Invest in legislative races, just like the union does.

This is an unsurprising statement to anyone with even a passing acquaintance with modern politics, but FEA Vice President Joanne McCall was aghast: “This video reveals that it’s all about the money.”

Now I do not defend the way big money is impacting modern politics or the coarse campaigns that are often a byproduct, but to be lectured on the evils of campaign spending by the FEA is surreal. It is the FEA’s primary political weapon. Since 2002, the FEA and its national affiliates have invested $20.1 million in Florida campaigns, according to the Florida Division of Elections. Its money is so integral to Florida Democratic legislators that no one raises an eyebrow when all the party’s House and Senate members meet, as they did on April 2, at FEA headquarters. The low-income parents for whom the school-choice movement fights don’t have money for campaigns. I am honored to fight for them and to help their voices be heard.

Here’s one way to measure the impact of the FEA’s spending: Democrats admirably fight to increase money for Florida’s pre-K program, even though it’s the nation’s largest voucher system — with 144,000 4-years-olds in private centers, many of them religious. Democrats also fight for Bright Futures scholarships, even though they help students of all incomes attend public and private universities — religious ones, too.

Yet Democrats this year oppose even a modest expansion for a scholarship that helps the poorest of K-12 students attend a private school. The difference: FEA represents employees in K-12 schools.

Across the country, the teacher unions’ increasingly adamant opposition to choices not employing unionized teachers, including charter schools and online courses, is creating fissures in the Democratic Party. National organizations such as Democrats for Education Reform and the Black Alliance for Educational Options are accelerating in membership. Just last month, New York Gov. Andrew Cuomo battled his state’s teachers union on charter schools. Also in New York, a bill to create a private school scholarship program modeled after Florida’s recently passed the state Senate with all but three Democrats in favor, and is co-sponsored in the Assembly by a majority of Democrats – and over 90 percent of the black and Hispanic caucus.

The FEA is certainly entitled to advance an educational agenda that serves the needs of its members, but its public disgust over campaign spending is a bit much to swallow. Whether or not a scholarship bill helping low-income children passes this year, let’s please drop the pretense that the union’s money is not part of the political equation.

You may also like


Parent and Teacher April 10, 2014 - 4:04 pm

Don’t put this on the FEA or Democrats.

It’s the Republicans who can’t get your legislation across the finish line. Your side has total control of the House, Senate, and executive branch. However, even Republicans in the Senate have balked at the proposals by SUFS the past few years. You could get your wish and have a dramatic expansion of vouchers if you would just agree to having voucher students take the same state tests as public school students. What in the world is SUFS so worried about?

Is there any circumstance where you would support voucher students taking the same tests as public school students?

Patrick R. Gibbons
Patrick R. Gibbons April 11, 2014 - 8:58 am

HI Parent and Teacher,

This article doesn’t have anything to do with Republican disagreement in the House and Senate. The context is about the FEA pointing to a small 527 that supports school choice and pretending to be shocked anyone would spend money in politics.

Step Up for Students’ Cynical Last-Minute Voucher Push | Scathing Purple Musings April 11, 2014 - 6:26 am

[…] to further empower and enrich the shady organization he founded. Writes John Kirtley in his redefinED […]

Dave Galloway April 11, 2014 - 7:01 am

The only reason that munch money has been sunk into politics is to offset the river of corporate dollars that have already inundated the political arena. I’m willing to wager that your corporate paymasters have spent far and above the $20 million figure quoted in your article. Vouchers are a scam that allow people such as yourself to get rich off the backs of children. Shame on you and your fellow corporate courtesans . . .

Patrick R. Gibbons
Patrick R. Gibbons April 11, 2014 - 9:00 am

Hi Dave,

Thanks for the comments but it is really hard for non-profits to get rich off anything, especially since the scholarships represent 1% of total K-12 ed spending in Florida… If you’re going to get rich off of education you might want to maintain the status quo… but that is another story.

Step Up for Students’ Cynical Last-Minute Voucher Push | Grumpy Opinions April 11, 2014 - 1:54 pm

[…] to further empower and enrich the shady organization he founded. Writes John Kirtley in his redefinED […]

Comments are closed.