For FL school choice scholarships, it’s which test, not whether to test

just the factsFlorida Senate President Don Gaetz says he wants low-income students on the Tax Credit Scholarship to take a different standardized test, but his message has gotten a bit garbled in translation.

Somehow, the word “different” keeps disappearing.

Gaetz is raising a perfectly legitimate issue – whether a proposed expansion of the 12-year-old scholarship program for economically disadvantaged students should include a requirement that the scholarship students take the same standardized test the state is getting ready to roll out for public students in 2015. That test will be tied to Florida’s version of the Common Core standards. Currently, scholarship students are taking nationally-normed standardized tests approved by the state.

Somehow, even some of the state’s best newspapers have gotten this distinction wrong.

One report called Gaetz’s idea “a dramatic swing in Florida’s experience with school choice, where critics have complained voucher programs were diluting public schools with no evidence they were improving the outcomes for poor children.” Another said that “Senate leaders are proposing for the first time that scholarship recipients take standardized tests.” An editorial asked of the academic achievement in the program: “How do we know”

This is important because the error feeds a narrative – there is “no evidence” the scholarships are helping children – that is wrong. (For the record, the scholarship program is administered by Step Up For Students, which co-hosts this blog.) Continue Reading →


Florida roundup: school choice, school grades, Common Core & more

Tax credit scholarships. House Speaker Will Weatherford says with tens of thousands of parents on waiting lists for tax credit scholarships, “Let us agree not to fight each other and instead fight for them.” The Buzz. Senate President reiterates his call for scholarship students to be assessed the same way as public school students. Orlando Sentinel. Gov. Scott doesn’t mention the scholarships or propose expansion. Times/Herald. More from the Sunshine State News. Tax credit scholarships are giving much-need options to the families who need them most, writes Rev. Robert Ward in the Tampa Bay Timesflorida-roundup-logo

Education savings accounts. “Personalized accounts for learning” gets a look in the House Choice & Innovation Committee. The Buzz. More from School Zone.

School choice. Counting its editorial against the proposed expansion of tax credit scholarships, the Orlando Sentinel runs a third opinion piece in a week against school choice. This one bizarrely accuses charter schools of circumventing church-state lines. The Palm Beach County School District considers a massive expansion of within-district school choice. Palm Beach Post.

Charter schools. One on the verge of being shut down in Broward finds a building in the nick of time. South Florida Sun Sentinel. Frank Biden, brother of Joe, is again pushing for charter schools in the Capitol. Post on Politics.

Common Core. Jeb Bush’s challenge. BBC News.

School grades. Senate Education Committee votes 5-1 for a simpler school grades formula. The Buzz. StateImpact Florida, Palm Beach Post, Northwest Florida Daily News. School grades are just part of the corporate reform ideology. Folio Weekly. Continue Reading →


At start of session, FL legislative leaders call for more school choice

Florida’s top lawmakers opened the legislative session Tuesday with calls to expand school choice.

House Speaker Will Weatherford and Senate President Don Gaetz have included the expansion of career education programs and tax credit scholarships in their agenda for the 60-day session.

In his remarks in the House chamber before Gov. Rick Scott’s state of the state speech, Weatherford, R-Wesley Chapel, framed the expansion of education options as part of an effort to fight “generational poverty.”

“I believe that no child’s success should ever be dictated by their zip code,” he said, appropriating a favorite line of former Gov. Jeb Bush.  “In my opinion, no other issue today personifies freedom, opportunity and the God-given right to rise better than the school choice movement.”

Referring to tax credit scholarships specifically, he added, “There are 60,000 kids who are receiving scholarships today, primarily minority and overwhelmingly low-income. And there are tens of thousands more parents looking for that same opportunity to provide their child with that choice.  Let’s agree not to fight each other. Let’s fight for them. Let’s expand the Florida Tax Credit Scholarship.”

The scholarship program is administered by Step Up For Students, which co-hosts this blog. You can read Weatherford’s full speech, as prepared for delivery, here.

Last session, Gaetz, R-Niceville, championed legislation that expanded career education programs offered by school districts. This year, he said, he wants lawmakers to lift funding caps on those programs.

Gaetz also said in his opening remarks that he wants to “end” the waiting list of students hoping to enroll in the tax credit scholarship program. At the same time, he said, the performance of students participating in the program “should be assessed just like the performance of any other child.”

The state does not require private school students who receive tax credit scholarships to take the state’s main standardized test, the FCAT (though some do). Students participating in the program are required, however, to take norm-referenced standardized tests approved by the Department of Education, which provides the data to an outside researcher for analysis.


Pastor: Let’s debate school choice scholarships with all facts on the table

Editor’s note: With debate heating up over a proposal to expand Florida’s tax credit scholarship program, a good amount of misinformation is circulating too. C.E. Glover, senior pastor and CEO of Mount Bethel Ministries, based in Fort Lauderdale, penned this op-ed in response to an editorial in the South Florida Sun Sentinel. The Sun Sentinel published Dr. Glover’s piece today. (And again for the record, the school choice scholarship program is administered by Step Up For Students, which co-hosts this blog.)

Dr. Glover

Dr. Glover

Since we opened Mount Bethel Christian Academy in 1990, we have worked with a steady stream of students who arrived in our classrooms academically behind. Many of them were in danger of falling through the cracks in school – and in life.

In recent years, many of them were able to come to us only because of Florida’s tax credit scholarship program, which offers educational options to the low-income parents who need them the most. And, I’m happy to report, many of those students have gone on to excel not only at our school, but in other schools both public and private.

I bring this up in response to the Sun-Sentinel’s editorial, “Make testing a part of state vouchers.” The suggestion that tax credit scholarship students should take the same standardized tests as public school students is worthy of serious public debate. All of us want to make sure that all students, whether they are in public school or private school or some other sector, are learning enough to succeed in a world that’s getting more competitive and complicated by the second.

But the Sun-Sentinel omitted some important details about the scholarship program that are vital to having an informed debate.

To be clear, tax credit scholarship students are not exempt from accountability tests. Since 2006, they have been required, by state law, to take a state-approved standardized test. At our school, they take the widely respected Stanford Achievement Test. The results are sent to a top-notch education researcher for analysis and comparison to public school students. Since 2010, state law has also required the public disclosure of average test score gains or losses for private schools with 30 or more students in tested grades.

We know two important things from the test data. First, the students who use tax credit scholarships tend to be the lowest-performing students in the public schools. That finding is in sync with our experiences. Second, scholarship students are making the same annual learning gains as students of all income levels nationally. That should be encouraging to parents, taxpayers and policy makers.

It’s worth noting that scholarship students are achieving these results with much less public funding than children in public schools. This year, the scholarship amount was $4,880. And though that’s roughly half of total government spending on children in Florida public schools, it still comes with meaningful requirements for financial accountability. Continue Reading →


Florida lawmakers to consider suite of school choice bills

A bill aimed at streamlining charter school applications and a proposed expansion of Florida’s tax credit scholarship program have gotten their share of headlines going in to the Florida legislative session that starts today.

Again this year, Florida lawmakers will consider a wide range of school choice bills, including a version of education savings accounts.

Again this year, Florida lawmakers will consider a wide range of school choice bills, including a version of education savings accounts.

But those are far from the only school choice measures in play. Here is a rundown, not quite exhaustive, of school choice legislation worth keeping an eye on over the next 60 days:

SB 850 would require community colleges to establish “collegiate high schools” that would be open to students throughout their target service areas. The new institutions would allow students to complete their first year of college by the time they receive their high school diplomas. A Senate panel today will consider merging it with a House bill that would create an “early warning system” for middle school students.

SB 790 has already gotten attention for increasing the state’s financial commitment to digital learning. A provision inserted by Sen. Jeff Brandes, R-St. Petersburg, should resonate with people following the effort to open a new charter school at MacDill Air Force Base. It would codify the Legislature’s intent to “encourage military installation commanders to collaboratively work with the Commissioner of Education to increase military family student achievement, which may include the establishment of charter schools on military installations.”

HB 533 aims to expand access to extracurricular activities for home-school, private school, charter school and virtual school students. Right now, state law allows those students to join sports teams at nearby public schools. This bipartisan proposal would broaden that provision to include performing arts, debate clubs and other extracurricular activities. It would also allow private school students to participate in activities at other schools in their district if they are zoned to a public school that doesn’t offer them.

SB 1512 , sponsored by Sen. Kelli Stargel, R-Lakeland, would create “Personalized Accounts for Learning,” similar to education savings accounts, for some students with disabilities. It would allow parents of children with conditions like autism and cerebral palsy to use up to 90 percent of the state’s core per-pupil funding to cover expenses like private school tuition, certain kinds of therapy, or instructional materials tailored to their child’s needs. The House Choice and Innovation Subcommittee is expected to discuss a similar idea today. Continue Reading →


Florida roundup: Common Core, testing, tax credit scholarships & more

Tax credit scholarships. House Speaker Will Weatherford and Americans for Prosperity tout the proposed program expansion (among other non-education-related issues) before the start of the session. Orlando Sentinel. Gets a mention in The Florida Current and Sunshine State News, too. Also gets a mention in this Times/Herald story, which oddly refers to the tax credit scholarship program as the ” ‘opportunity scholarship’ voucher program” and says Republicans are moving ahead on it “to appeal to their political base and special-interest groups.” First Coast News in Jacksonville logs in a brief story. (Full disclosure: The program is administered by Step Up For Students, which co-hosts this blog.)

florida-roundup-logoDual enrollment. State Sen. John Legg, R-Lutz, proposes “collegiate high schools” tied to Florida colleges that would help students earn more college credit and industry certifications. Orlando Sentinel.

Magnet schools. Supply and demand doesn’t match up for magnet programs in Orange. School Zone.

Common Core. As the legislative session begins, the conversation shifts from what’s in them to how to implement. StateImpact Florida. Does Jeb Bush realize what Common Core will do to school choice? Fox News, picking up EAG.

Teacher unions. Intercepts logs in the “melodrama” from the election for a new head of the Broward union.

Teacher evals. VAM is “bureaucratic baloney,” writes Tampa Tribune columnist Joe Henderson.

Testing. Florida Education Commissioner Pam Stewart takes on the Florida Education Association’s criticism of testing for special-needs students. Gradebook. Extra Credit. Answer Sheet.

Education spending. Mo’ money, mo’ problems for the Leg this year? Sarasota Herald Tribune. Continue Reading →


School choice, equal opportunity and America’s promise

Father Scully

Father Scully

Many talk school choice and equal opportunity, but few do it as persuasively as Father Tim Scully.

Scully founded the Alliance for Catholic Education at the University of Notre Dame, a group working to transform and revive Catholic schools. A priest and political scientist, he pitches school choice as fundamentally American – or, at least, fundamental to an America that strives to live up to its ideals.podcastED-logo

“That’s a central tenet of our creed that we promise to every citizen … (that) every child will have an equal opportunity to realize his or her potential. And that is simply false. Simply false in this country,” Scully told redefinED in the podcast interview attached below. “How can we look in the mirror and kind of say, ‘Yeah, American democracy is a function of fair democracy’ when we don’t allow kids and parents to have a decent opportunity to escape the poverty under which they often have been born?”

Scully’s group is making the mirror more forgiving. ACE helps prepare teachers and leaders to work in inner-city Catholic schools. Its ACE Academies are turning a handful of  Catholic schools (including two in Florida) into models of reform. And for five months now, its reps have been criss-crossing the country in an RV to raise awareness about the value that Catholic schools have for all of us, whether we’re Catholic or not. (Scully was on a Florida leg of the tour when he stopped to chat with redefinED.) Last fall, Scully’s leadership earned him the William E. Simon Prize for Lifetime Achievement in Social Entrepreneurship from the Manhattan Institute.

Expanding school choice is key to Catholic school revitalization. Unlike their counterparts in other states, Catholic schools in Florida are seeing enrollment growth thanks to vouchers and tax credit scholarships. But, Scully said, support for school choice obviously goes far beyond its impact on any particular education sector. Continue Reading →


redefinED roundup: de Blasio goes after charters, vouchers and racism in NC, virtual school debate in ME


Alaska: A lack of capital funding impedes charter school growth in the state (Anchorage Daily News). Gov. Sean Parnell wants to allow charter schools to have access to district transportation funds (KTUU, Associated Press). School choice will benefit rural students (Juneau Empire).

Arizona: A former high school teacher says vouchers for private tuition are like privately run prison systems (Ahwataukee Foothills News).

California: A virtual school student wins a school video contest sponsored by the White House (The Cambrian).

D.C.: Rocketship charter schools expand to the city (Education Week).

Florida: House Speaker Will Weatherford releases a bill to expand the tax-credit scholarship program (The Ledger, News 13, Tampa Bay Times, Associated PressWEAR TV). School choice gets support from the Jewish community in south Florida (Jewish Journal). Private schools and parents may not want to take the FCAT (Orlando Sentinel). A lecturer at the University of Central Florida says private schools accepting tax credit scholarships should administer standardized tests to students (note: the law already requires tax credit scholarship students to take national norm-referenced standardized tests) (Orlando Sentinel). The Orlando Sentinel editorial board says private school scholarship students should take standardized tests (state law already requires tax-credit scholarship students to take norm-referenced standardized tests). So does the South Florida Sun Sentinel editorial board. The Tampa Tribune supports the expansion. Tampa Bay Times columnist John Romano says tax-credit scholarships have no accountability and reduce public school per-pupil spending. Charter Schools USA operates 34 schools in the state, but one “F” and one “D” rated school encouraged Orange and Seminole County school districts to repeatedly deny applications to expand (Orlando Sentinel). Broward County school superintendent Robert Runcie collaborates with charter schools (Education Week). Continue Reading →